Back to Popular

Does Fish Oil Go Rancid?

Does Fish Oil Go Rancid?
Supplements Guide 12 May 2026

Omega 3 fats are highly unsaturated, which is what makes them biologically useful and also what makes them chemically fragile. They oxidise readily on exposure to heat, light and air.

What does oxidation produce?

A range of breakdown products including peroxides and aldehydes, which are responsible for the characteristic rancid smell and taste.

Standards exist for peroxide value, anisidine value and a combined measure called TOTOX, which industry bodies use to define acceptable freshness.

How common is the problem?

Independent analyses of fish oil supplements in several countries have found substantial proportions exceeding recommended oxidation limits.

Some studies have found the majority of tested products above at least one threshold, which is a notable finding for a widely used supplement.

Flavourings such as lemon or orange can mask the taste of oxidised oil, which complicates consumer detection.

Does it matter?

The health significance of consuming oxidised omega 3 is not fully established. Oxidation products have been shown to have adverse effects in laboratory studies.

At minimum, oxidised oil contains less intact EPA and DHA than the label states, so you are getting less than you paid for.

Some research has suggested oxidised fish oil may not produce the expected effects on blood lipids, which would be one explanation for inconsistent trial findings.

How can you tell?

  • Cut open a capsule and smell it, since fresh fish oil smells mild rather than strongly fishy
  • Taste a small amount, which should not be bitter or acrid
  • Note whether the fishy repeat is severe, which often indicates oxidation
  • Check the expiry date and how long the bottle has been open

The fishy burp many people attribute to fish oil generally is often a sign of a poor quality or oxidised product rather than an inevitable feature.

How should it be stored?

In the fridge once opened, away from light and heat. Liquid oils are more vulnerable than capsules because of greater air exposure.

Buying smaller quantities more frequently reduces the time a bottle spends open.

What reduces oxidation?

Antioxidants such as vitamin E are commonly added, and many products include them.

Opaque bottles, nitrogen flushing and appropriate packaging all help, which is one argument for choosing established manufacturers.

What should you look for?

Third party testing certification, a recent manufacture or expiry date, and packaging that protects from light.

Programmes exist that test for oxidation as well as contaminants, and products carrying such certification offer more assurance.

What is the summary?

Fish oil oxidises easily, many products on sale are past acceptable limits, and the fishy repeat is a useful warning sign rather than a normal feature.

This article is general information and not medical advice.

Does oxidation affect the health claims?

It may explain some inconsistency in trial results, since a supplement containing degraded omega 3 would not be expected to produce the same effects as a fresh one.

Few trials have reported the oxidation status of the products used, which is a gap in the literature.

Are capsules safer than liquid?

Capsules protect the oil from air until opened, which reduces oxidation compared with a bottle used over several weeks.

Liquid products are cheaper per gram and require more careful storage and quicker use.

What is the summary?

Fish oil oxidises readily, testing has found many products above acceptable limits, and severe fishy repeat is a warning sign rather than a normal feature.

Store it in the fridge, buy sizes you will finish, and smell a capsule if you are unsure.

Does it affect all forms equally?

Liquid oils are most vulnerable, capsules less so, and products with added antioxidants and protective packaging less again.

Krill oil contains astaxanthin naturally, which provides some protection against oxidation.

Does it explain the fishy repeat?

Often. Fresh, well made fish oil produces far less repeat than an oxidised product, so severe aftertaste is worth treating as information rather than as inevitable.

Switching to a fresher product or a different form frequently resolves it.