Supplement pricing is presented in ways that make comparison difficult, and a two step calculation resolves most of it.
What is the first step?
Cost per day at the recommended dose.
Divide the price by the number of servings in the container, which requires checking how many capsules make a serving.
A cheap bottle requiring four capsules daily can cost more per day than an expensive one requiring one.
What is the second step?
Cost per unit of the ingredient you actually want.
Divide the daily cost by the milligrams of that ingredient supplied daily.
This matters most for products where doses vary widely, including magnesium, curcuminoids and omega 3.
What does this reveal?
- Low dose products that look cheap and are poor value
- Products where most of the price reflects marketing rather than content
- Cases where a supermarket own brand is equivalent
- Multi-ingredient products supplying token amounts of everything
What about bulk buying?
Larger containers usually cost less per serving, provided you will finish them before the best before date.
For probiotics and oils, buying smaller quantities more often may be better despite the higher unit price.
What about subscriptions?
Subscription discounts can be genuine, and automatic renewal removes the moment at which you would reassess whether you still want the product.
Setting a review date is worth doing alongside any subscription.
Should you always buy the cheapest?
No. Third party testing, disclosed doses and reputable manufacture are worth paying something for.
The calculation tells you what you are paying for, which is the point rather than minimising cost.
What is the summary?
Cost per day at your actual dose, then cost per milligram of what you want. Two calculations that frequently reverse which product looks better.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What about multi-ingredient products?
Comparing a multivitamin against separate supplements requires deciding which nutrients you actually want.
A multivitamin is usually cheaper than buying its components separately and supplies less of each.
What about own brand products?
Supermarket and pharmacy own brands frequently contain the same forms at the same doses for considerably less.
For basic vitamins and minerals the difference in composition is often nil.
What is the summary?
Cost per day at your actual dose, then cost per milligram of what you want. Two calculations that frequently reverse which product looks better value.
What about postage and subscriptions?
Delivery charges and minimum order values change the real cost, particularly for smaller purchases.
Including them in the calculation gives a truer comparison.
What is the practical method?
Price divided by servings gives cost per day, and that divided by the milligrams of active gives cost per unit.
Two divisions, done once, and applicable to every future purchase in that category.
Is cheapest ever right?
For basic vitamins and minerals in standard forms, own brand products are frequently equivalent to premium ones.
For products where testing and standardisation matter, paying more can be justified.
Knowing which situation you are in is what the calculation gives you.
What about time?
The calculation takes two minutes and applies to every subsequent purchase in that category.
For anything taken daily over months, that is a reasonable investment.
It also frequently identifies that a cheaper product is equivalent.
What does this reveal most often?
That heavily marketed products cost several times more per unit of active ingredient than equivalent alternatives.
It also identifies products whose low headline price reflects a very low dose.
Both are common and neither is visible without calculating.
What is the practical method?
Two divisions, done once for each product, giving cost per day and cost per milligram of active.
Write the figures down and comparison becomes trivial thereafter.
Most people never do this and are surprised by the result when they do.
A spreadsheet is unnecessary; the back of an envelope does it.