Menopause has generated a substantial supplement market, and several of those products interact with hormone replacement therapy or carry concerns of their own.
What reduces HRT effectiveness?
St Johns wort induces the enzymes metabolising oestrogen, reducing blood levels and potentially reducing symptom control.
It is frequently taken for low mood during menopause, which makes the combination common and the interaction easy to miss.
What about black cohosh?
It is among the most studied menopause supplements, with trials producing mixed results for hot flushes.
Cases of liver injury have been reported and prompted regulatory review, and UK products carry warnings about liver reactions.
Anyone taking it should stop and seek advice if they develop jaundice, dark urine or persistent nausea.
What about phytoestrogens?
Soy isoflavones and red clover contain compounds with weak oestrogenic activity.
Evidence for symptom relief is inconsistent, and effects are generally modest where present.
Anyone with a history of hormone sensitive breast cancer should discuss these with their team before taking them, since the theoretical concern about oestrogenic activity has not been fully resolved.
What else is marketed?
- Sage, with limited evidence for hot flushes
- Evening primrose oil, with largely negative trial findings
- Magnesium, commonly taken for sleep and mood
- Various combination products with multiple botanical ingredients
Does HRT itself affect nutrients?
Oral oestrogen has been associated with modest effects on some nutrients, and it also improves calcium retention and bone density.
Bone protection is one of its established benefits rather than a concern.
What about DHEA?
Sold as a supplement in some countries, it is a hormone precursor and is not available as a general supplement in the UK.
Products bought abroad or online should be discussed with a prescriber rather than combined with HRT independently.
What should you do?
Tell whoever prescribes your HRT what else you take, and check anything new against it.
What is the summary?
St Johns wort reduces effectiveness, black cohosh carries liver warnings, and phytoestrogens warrant discussion for anyone with hormone sensitive cancer.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What about bone health?
Bone loss accelerates after menopause, and calcium, vitamin D and weight bearing exercise all matter regardless of whether HRT is used.
HRT itself protects bone, which is one of its established benefits.
What about supplements and breast cancer risk?
Anyone with a personal or strong family history of hormone sensitive cancer should discuss phytoestrogen containing products with their team.
The evidence is not settled, which is itself a reason to ask rather than assume.
What is the summary?
St Johns wort reduces effectiveness, black cohosh carries liver warnings, and phytoestrogens warrant discussion for anyone with hormone sensitive cancer.
What about non-hormonal options?
Several non-hormonal prescribed treatments exist for menopausal symptoms, alongside behavioural approaches with reasonable evidence.
These are worth discussing where HRT is not suitable, rather than working through supplement options alone.
What about combination products?
Menopause supplements frequently contain several botanicals at low doses, which makes attributing any effect or problem difficult.
What about sleep and mood?
Sleep disturbance and low mood are common during menopause and have their own treatment options.
Reaching for St Johns wort for mood is precisely how the HRT interaction arises.
What should you tell your prescriber?
Everything you take for menopausal symptoms, including anything bought without prescription.
Several of these products have genuine pharmacological activity rather than being inert.
What about long term use?
Several menopause supplements are taken for years without review, and black cohosh in particular has recommended duration limits.
Periodic reassessment applies here as with any long term product.
What about symptom tracking?
Recording symptoms weekly makes it possible to judge whether anything is helping, since menopausal symptoms fluctuate considerably.
Menopause care has expanded considerably, and a GP can discuss the full range of options available.
Symptoms vary enormously between individuals, which makes personalised advice more useful than general recommendations.
A GP appointment specifically about menopause is a reasonable thing to request.