Vegan and vegetarian marks vary between independently certified trademarks and statements a manufacturer has written themselves.
What is the difference?
Certified marks require an application, verification of ingredients and processes, and ongoing compliance with the certifying organisations standards.
Suitable for vegans printed as text is a manufacturer statement, which may be accurate and has not been independently checked.
What do certified marks cover?
- All ingredients, including processing aids not always on the label
- The capsule or tablet materials
- In some schemes, absence of animal testing
- Manufacturing processes where animal derived materials might be used
Which supplement ingredients are animal derived?
Gelatin in capsules and softgels, from bovine or porcine sources.
Vitamin D3 from lanolin, which is sheep derived, though lichen derived versions exist.
Omega 3 from fish, with algal alternatives available.
Glucosamine from shellfish, with fermentation derived alternatives.
Shellac in some tablet coatings, which comes from insects.
Some vitamin A and vitamin E sources, and certain probiotic growth media.
Why is D3 a common problem?
Because D3 is more effective than D2, and the standard source is lanolin.
Lichen derived D3 solves this and costs more, which is why products state it prominently when used.
What about cross contamination?
Certification schemes address manufacturing processes to varying degrees, which matters more for strict adherence than for dietary preference.
What should you check?
The capsule material and the source of any vitamin D, which between them account for most problems.
What is the summary?
Certified marks involve independent verification, self declared statements do not, and capsule material plus vitamin D source are the two things worth checking.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What about products with no statement?
Where nothing is stated, gelatin capsules are the likely default, since they are cheaper than plant based alternatives.
Manufacturers using vegetarian capsules generally say so, because it costs more and is a selling point.
Do certification schemes cover testing?
Some vegan schemes include a requirement that products are not tested on animals, which is a separate commitment from the ingredients.
Scheme requirements differ, so checking what a particular mark covers is worthwhile.
What about religious dietary requirements?
Halal and kosher certification are separate schemes with their own requirements and marks.
Vegetarian certification does not automatically satisfy them, and vice versa.
What is the summary?
Certified marks involve independent verification while self declared statements do not, and capsule material plus vitamin D source account for most problems.
What about softgels?
Softgel capsules used for oils are usually gelatin, which makes many omega 3 and vitamin D products unsuitable for vegetarians.
Vegetarian softgels exist and cost more.
Algal omega 3 in a vegetarian capsule is the fully plant based option.
What should vegans check?
Capsule material, vitamin D source, omega 3 source and any glucosamine.
Those four account for most animal derived ingredients in common supplements.
Certified products remove the need to check each time.
What about honesty of self declaration?
Most self declared statements are accurate, since manufacturers have little to gain from being wrong about it.
Certification adds verification rather than replacing an otherwise dishonest claim.
For strict adherence, verification is worth having.
For dietary preference, a self declared statement is usually sufficient.
What is the practical position?
Check the capsule and the vitamin D source, prefer certified marks for strict adherence, and accept self declaration for preference.
Those cover almost all cases.
Manufacturers will confirm sources on request where a label is unclear.
Reformulation is worth rechecking for.
What about children and gelatin?
Childrens supplements frequently use gelatin in chewables and gummies, which is worth checking for families avoiding it.
Pectin based alternatives are widely available.
Labels usually state which is used.
Certified marks remove the need to check ingredients individually each time.
For anyone strictly avoiding animal products that convenience is worth something.
Ingredient lists remain the definitive source where no certification appears.
Reading them takes a moment.