Butterbur is a rare case of a herbal supplement with reasonable efficacy evidence that was withdrawn on safety grounds.
What is butterbur?
An extract of Petasites hybridus, a marshland plant, standardised for compounds called petasins.
The plant also naturally contains pyrrolizidine alkaloids, which are toxic to the liver and are the source of the problem.
What do people take it for?
Migraine prevention, which is the use with the strongest evidence.
Allergic rhinitis, where some trials found butterbur comparable to antihistamines.
What did the research show?
Trials of standardised butterbur extract reported reductions in migraine frequency compared with placebo.
The evidence was considered strong enough that neurological guidance once recommended it, a recommendation later withdrawn over safety.
What are pyrrolizidine alkaloids?
Naturally occurring plant compounds that cause liver damage and are considered carcinogenic.
They occur in several plants including comfrey and ragwort, and cause a serious condition affecting the veins of the liver.
Extraction processes can remove them, and products described as PA free are intended to have done so.
What happened in the UK?
The medicines regulator advised against use of unlicensed butterbur products following reports of liver reactions.
Products were withdrawn from sale in the UK and in several other European countries.
Cases of serious liver injury, including some requiring transplant, have been reported internationally.
Are PA free products safe?
The alkaloid content is the identified hazard, and liver injury cases have been reported with products marketed as PA free.
Whether other compounds contribute, or whether removal was incomplete, has not been resolved.
What should you do if you take it?
Stop and speak to a GP, particularly if you obtained it from an overseas seller.
Warning signs of liver problems include jaundice, dark urine, itching, nausea and abdominal pain.
What are the alternatives for migraine?
- Prescribed preventive medicines, which have substantial evidence
- Riboflavin and magnesium, both with modest supporting evidence
- Identifying and managing triggers
- Treating medication overuse headache where present
A GP can discuss preventive treatment for anyone having frequent migraines.
What does butterbur illustrate?
That a plant can contain both a useful compound and a toxic one, and that natural origin says nothing about safety.
What is the summary?
Butterbur is taken for migraine and hay fever, has genuine efficacy evidence, and was withdrawn in the UK because of liver toxicity.
This article is general information and not medical advice.
What dose was studied?
Migraine trials generally used 75 milligrams of standardised extract twice daily over three to four months.
That is the amount associated with the reported benefit and also with the exposure that raised concern.
Is it still available?
It can still be found through overseas online sellers, which places it outside UK oversight entirely.
Products obtained that way carry no assurance about alkaloid content.
Why does this matter beyond butterbur?
Because several other plants contain the same class of alkaloids, including comfrey, and contamination of herbal teas with alkaloid containing weeds has been documented.
It is a good illustration of why botanical sourcing and testing matter.
What should you do instead?
See a GP about migraine prevention, since several effective licensed options exist and frequent migraine is worth treating properly.
Keeping a headache diary helps identify patterns and supports treatment decisions.
Who should take butterbur?
Nobody, on current UK advice, and certainly not products obtained from overseas sellers.
What does butterbur illustrate?
That efficacy and safety are separate questions, and that a supplement can perform well on one while failing badly on the other.
Regulators withdrew it despite the migraine evidence rather than because it did not work.
That is an unusual and instructive case.
What should you check?
Whether any herbal product you take is known to contain pyrrolizidine alkaloids, and whether the manufacturer tests for them.
Comfrey is the other common example.