Melanin, the pigment that gives skin its colour, absorbs ultraviolet light. That is largely its purpose, and it works well. It also absorbs the specific UVB wavelengths that skin uses to make vitamin D, which means the same time in the same sunlight produces less vitamin D in darker skin than in lighter skin.
How large is the difference?
Estimates vary between studies and depend on how skin tone is classified, but the effect is substantial rather than marginal. Research has suggested that people with the darkest skin may need several times the sun exposure of someone with very pale skin to synthesise a comparable amount.
The mechanism is straightforward competition. UVB entering the skin can either be absorbed by melanin or reach the compound that becomes vitamin D. More melanin means more of the available UVB is intercepted before it does the latter.
This is not a defect. It is an adaptation to high ultraviolet environments, where protection against UV damage and folate breakdown carried more weight than efficient vitamin D synthesis. The mismatch appears when that skin is in a place like the UK, where UVB is scarce for half the year to begin with.
What does UK guidance advise?
People with darker skin, specifically including those of African, African Caribbean and South Asian background, are advised to take a daily 10 microgram vitamin D supplement all year round rather than only in autumn and winter.
That differs from the general advice, which suggests considering a supplement from about October to March and relying on sunlight through the summer. The year round recommendation exists because summer sunlight at British latitudes cannot be relied upon to close the gap.
The same year round advice applies to other groups for related reasons, including people who cover most of their skin outdoors, those who are housebound, and people in care homes.
Is more sun exposure a reasonable answer instead?
It is a reasonable partial answer in summer and not a complete one. Longer exposure does produce more vitamin D, and skin of any tone can burn given enough ultraviolet, so the strategy has a ceiling set by skin safety.
Between October and March the question does not arise, because UVB does not reach the ground in useful amounts at these latitudes regardless of skin tone. Nobody makes meaningful vitamin D in a British January.
A 10 microgram supplement costs very little and removes the need to calculate any of this. That is the practical argument for the year round advice.
Why are the blood test thresholds debated?
This is a genuinely unsettled area worth knowing about. Studies in the United States have repeatedly found that Black adults show lower total 25-hydroxyvitamin D on average, yet have higher bone density and lower fracture rates than White adults with higher measured levels.
One proposed explanation involves vitamin D binding protein. Most circulating vitamin D is bound to this protein and biologically inactive, and only the free fraction is available to tissues. Some research has suggested that differences in binding protein levels mean free vitamin D is more similar between groups than the total measurement implies, though this work has been methodologically contested.
The practical upshot is uncertainty rather than a rule. Current UK thresholds are applied to everyone, and clinicians generally interpret a result alongside symptoms, calcium, and bone health rather than in isolation.
Does any of this change the dose?
Not for standard supplementation. The advised amount is the same 10 micrograms daily, with the difference being that it is recommended for the whole year rather than only the darker months.
Higher doses are appropriate for confirmed deficiency, which is treated the same way in everyone: a prescribed loading course followed by maintenance. Body weight is a separate factor that may warrant more, since vitamin D distributes into fat tissue.
Anyone with bone pain, muscle weakness or symptoms suggesting deficiency should see a GP rather than increasing the dose independently, since the safe upper level of 100 micrograms a day applies to everyone regardless of skin tone.
This article is general information and not medical advice.