Is Cod Liver Oil the Same as Fish Oil?
No. Cod liver oil contains vitamins A and D from the liver, which brings a specific caution about retinol that ordinary fish oil does not.
These are the supplements you have seen advertised, and they are where the gap between the claim and the evidence is widest. A few hold up better than their reputation suggests. Several are sold on studies that do not say what the label implies. Some have nothing behind them at all beyond a good-looking tub. We say which, and show our working.
No. Cod liver oil contains vitamins A and D from the liver, which brings a specific caution about retinol that ordinary fish oil does not.
Most contain stimulant laxatives, which produce water loss rather than fat loss. Regular use causes dependence and electrolyte problems.
Olive leaf extract is taken for blood pressure, cholesterol and immune support. The blood pressure evidence is the strongest of the three.
Garlic supplements are taken for blood pressure and cholesterol. Blood pressure has the better evidence, with modest reductions in meta-analyses.
Both have more research than most greens ingredients, mostly small studies on blood lipids. Both also carry specific contamination considerations.
The dose that matters is whatever the research on that strain used, typically one to ten billion. Very high counts are a marketing feature rather than a benefit.
Trials typically used 500 to 1500mg of curcuminoids daily, frequently in enhanced formulations. The number on a label often refers to turmeric extract instead.
Most trials used 300 to 600mg of standardised extract daily. The withanolide percentage matters more than the milligram figure on the front.
Skin studies used 2.5 to 10 grams daily and joint studies around 10 grams, with undenatured type II at 40 milligrams. The right dose depends on which product you have.
There is reasonable evidence in rheumatoid arthritis, including reduced painkiller use. Evidence in osteoarthritis is much weaker.
It has an authorised European health claim at three grams daily, which is rare in this category. It also carries a genuine choking risk.
Any noticeable effect usually comes from added caffeine or from B vitamins that permit an energy claim without producing an energy effect.